Recipes with Halloween Candy - A Beautifully Fit Soul

If you are looking for ways to use up all of your leftover Halloween candy look no further than this roundup of 25+ recipes with Halloween Candy! These are all simple homemade dessert recipes that are great for fall and even Thanksgiving. Most of these dessert recipes are quick and easy and a few of them are no bake. There are quite a few recipes for cookies with Halloween Candy and also cake with halloween candy. These are some of the best dessert recipes for Halloween especially if you are hosting a Halloween party! If you are looking for tasty dessert recipes that use cream cheese, there are a number of cheesecake recipes as well!

Table of Contents

What Dessert Recipes Should I Make This Fall?

Candy Pizza Cookie With Leftover Halloween Candy from frugalcouponliving.com

‘Whether you have leftovers in November, leftover candy in March, or lets get real, Halloween Candy is gone by November 1st and you never have leftovers at all, we have the tastiest Candy Pizza Cookie for you!’ – frugalcouponliving.com

Halloween Candy Trifle from crayonsandcravings.com

‘A delicious and easy to make Halloween trifle made with HERSHEY® Halloween candy, chocolate brownies, pudding, and whipped topping.’ – crayonsandcravings.com

No Bake Peanut Butter Cheesecake from missinthekitchen.com

‘No Bake Peanut Butter Cheesecake is a super easy and delicious dessert for any occasion. This quick dessert comes together in just five minutes with only 5 ingredients!’ – missinthekitchen.com

No Bake Peanut Butter Cheesecake - recipes with halloween candy — Photo from missinthekitchen.com

Caramel Skillet Brownie from homebodyeats.com

‘Put your leftover Halloween candy to good use with these caramel skillet brownies. Bonus points for adding ice cream!‘ – homebodyeats.com

HALLOWEEN CANDY COOKIE BARS

Candy Cookie Bars from joyfoodsunshine.com

‘The perfect dessert recipe to use up that Halloween Candy or adapt them for any holiday.’ – joyfoodsunshine.com ]

Reese’s Pieces Cake Mix Cookie Bars from snacksandsips.com

‘Easy to make Reese’s Pieces Cake Mix Cookie Bars are the perfect quick treat. Loaded with candy pieces, this is a great dessert in a flash.’ – snacksandsips.com

Candy Cookie Bar Using Leftover Halloween Candy from ottawamommyclub.ca

‘If you have a large amount of candy and need some ideas of what to do with it then this candy cookie bar recipe using leftover Halloween candy is exactly what you need.’ – ottawamommyclub.ca

Chocolate Chip Cookie Cheesecake Bites (Halloween) from theforkedspoon.com

‘Made with homemade chocolate chip cookie dough, cheesecake, Fun Size M&M’S®, SNICKERS® & TWIX® candies from your local Walmart, these delicious Cheesecake Bites are guaranteed to be the hit of any party.’ – theforkedspoon.com

Leftover Candy Stuffed Brownies from leelalicious.com

‘Use up leftover candy from Halloween, Christmas or Easter and make Candy-Stuffed Brownies.’ – leelalicious.com

Easy No Bake Leftover Halloween Candy Recipe from julieblanner.com

‘An easy No Bake Leftover Halloween Candy recipe is a perfect way to use up all that trick or treat candy. A little sweet, a little salty and a lot of crunch from all those candy bars (hello, snickers!). It’s a festive holiday dessert wrapped into a bar – I dare you to have just one!’ – julieblanner.com

Almond Joy Hot Chocolate Bombs with Marshmallows from babaganosh.org

‘These Almost Joy Hot Chocolate Bombs are literally the best. You’ll never go back to drinking your hot chocolate any other way. With just 5 simple ingredients needed, they’re fast and easy to make, and even more fun to share with someone you love!’ – babaganosh.org

HALLOWEEN CANDY BAR COOKIES

Snickers Stuffed Cookies from playpartyplan.com

‘Snickers cookies are a soft and fluffy peanut butter cookie filled with a Snickers candy bar then drizzled with a chocolate finish.‘ – playpartyplan.com

Peanut Butter Cup Cookies from drugstoredivas.com

Perfect way to use up your leftover peanut butter cups (if you have any!)

Tasty Mars Bars Stuffed Cookies from x0x0bella.com

‘Do you like Mars bars? If so, you will love these Mars bar stuffed cookies. This stuffed cookie recipe combines all the sweet indulgence of Mars bars with everything you love about cookies!’ – xoxobella.com

Kitchen Sink Cookies from emilyfabulous.com

‘If you love chocolate chip cookies then you HAVE to try these Kitchen Sink Cookies! Also called Dump Cookies, Everything Cookies, or Pantry Cookies, they have sweet, salty, and crunchy goodies to make them a new favorite in your house!’ – emilyfabulous.com

Candy Bar Cookies from amandascookin.com

‘I’m a peanut butter cookie fan for sure, but adding candy bars into the mix is a real bonus. During cookie making season (AKA the holidays) I always try to get a batch of these delicious candy bar cookies into the mix. They are always a hit and can be made and devoured any time of the year!’ – amandascookin.com

Candy Corn Cookies from budgetdelicious.com

‘If you love chocolate, these Candy Corn Cookies are triple chocolate heaven! These easy-to-make cookies are the perfect fall or Halloween treat.’ – budgetdelicious.com

Halloween Candy Cookies from thecookiedoughdiaries.com

‘These Halloween Candy Cookies are a perfect way to use up all that leftover Halloween candy. They take less than 30 minutes and are easy and super customize-able. The cookie base is gooey and soft and each bite is loaded with meltey Halloween candy!’ – thecookiedoughdiaries.com

Candy Bar Fondue from themagicalslowcooker.com

‘Use up leftover candy with this Slow Cooker Candy Bar Fondue!! Great with pound cake, strawberries and apples!’ – themagicalslowcooker.com

Cookie Butter Kit Kat Cookie Pie from sweetrecipes.com

‘This Cookie Butter Kit Kat Cookie Pie is filled with cookie butter and Kit Kat candy bar pieces all baked into a pie shell.’ – sweetrecipes.com

Air Fryer Twix Cupcakes from thesixfiguredish.com

‘These Air Fryer Twix Cupcakes are the ultimate dessert to make on special occasions like birthdays or holidays!’ – thesixfiguredish.com

Easy Halloween Cupcakes with Leftover Candy from venture1105.com

‘Follow these tips and learn how to decorate Halloween cupcakes! It’s a fun way to use all that leftover Trick or Treat candy.’ – venture1105.com

Halloween Candy Bark from ourcraftymom.com

‘Make fun Halloween candy bark using all of your trick or treaters favorite Halloween candy! – ourcraftymom.com

Leftover Halloween Candy Recipe from ohmy-creative.com

‘Just 3 ingredients in this leftover Halloween candy recipe – a tasty sweet and salty treat! Easy for the kids to make into a Thanksgiving treat!’ – ohmy-creative.com

Reese’s Cake With Peanut Butter Cream Cheese Frosting from spiceandsugarmama.com

Reese’s Cake with Peanut Butter Cream Cheese Frosting will transform a box cake into something spectacular. The whipped topping and Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups take this cake to the next level. This is the easiest way to enjoy a peanut butter and chocolate cake any night. – spiceandsugarmama.com

Non-Food Ideas

Skittle Rainbow Experiment from partieswithacause.com

‘If you love color, you’ll LOVE this Skittles rainbow experiment! It’s a science and math activity all in one. The perfect way to use up left over holiday candy or a tasty way to teach your kiddos at home.’ – partieswithacause.com

More Recipes!

If you are looking for more fall recipes you can check out my best pumpkin bread recipe or my recipe for spiced cider! Let me know if you try any of these recipes out over on Instagram or in my private FB group!

Pin6

6 Shares